Which is better JAL or ANA Business class and why?

I was thinking about this today and I wondering what everyone else thinks about this and why?

I am just after a broad perspective on this as there are many differences between the two products and I am sure most of you have a preference for personal reasons which is what I am hoping you will share with us.

 

As a Milepoint Guide, you should know better there are numerous C products on JAL and ANA. You need to be more specific and set a good example here.

 

Edited the first post to clarify point of this discussion.

 

still too vague
I assume you meant international C? To be honest, you probably get a better comparison from more people if you ask this on FT. There are way more people contributing over there.

I like NH longhaul C having a la carte menu while JL only have them on the real longhaul flights, e.g. NRT-LAX doesn't have it.

 

Of course international C as there is no domestic Business class called "Executive class".

Good to hear your response. Thank you.

 

Now you are making this non-newbie friendly.

 

NH C for the new seats (don't like any airlines slope seats), and the NH menu is great ! Many moons ago I used to enjoy JL service but over the years became less enamored !

 

FYI I did not vote

 

Is this info for me....or the other guy?

 

For other people. Somehow Simon chooses to make the votes private and I don't want to give people the impression that I actually participated in this poll. There are two people who have voted so far and two provided comments. Simon didn't vote when I first responded.

FYI I am in the disgruntled MPer mode right now and want to minimize my content posting here to a minimum That's why I don't want to vote

 

So do tell why you are disgruntled.......let it all out!

 

I might try and check NH biz to MNL from NRT next week if I get upgraded. I'll compare things then.