I'm up for my annual renewal with Amica. Have been with them for about seven years or so. Sick of the annual increases (up another 12% this year), despite no tickets or accidents. The increases are probably today's reality, but I'm looking for suggestions on a better, lower-costing insurer. Amica is pretty highly rated with the likes of the Consumer Reports survey and JD Power, which leans me towards them when it comes to premiums around the same price. I don't qualify for USAA or NJM (other top-rated insurers). I have looked at a couple of smaller insurers, but just on auto alone, they are about the same as my current policy, if not a tad more. Does anyone have any suggestions on insurers or a website I can go to (tried insure.com already) for good rates?